Brewers FeedDustin May
P · Age 29 · Bats Right · Throws Right
Where things stand
Dustin May underperformed during the Brewers' NLCS sweep of the Dodgers, failing to deliver on his role as a deadline acquisition meant to bolster Milwaukee's pitching depth. The 29-year-old right-hander, acquired from the Cardinals in July, had posted a 5.65 ERA in 36.2 innings with the Brewers down the stretch but was initially selected as the Game 3 NLDS starter against San Diego based on his strong historical record against that team. Though May contributed to a record-breaking five perfect innings by four relievers in Game 2 of the NLCS, his overall postseason performance did not justify the trade deadline investment.
Synthesized by MLB Feed Network from the 55 stories below. How we write these
2026 season
Stats from the MLB Stats API.
Contract
See the full Brewers payroll.
Dustin May coverage
Brewers' dominant NLCS victory over Dodgers vindicates Matt Arnold’s trade deadline strategy
The Milwaukee Brewers swept the Los Angeles Dodgers in the NLCS, validating general manager Matt Arnold's trade deadline approach of acquiring multiple role players rather than pursuing a single star pitcher like Tarik Skubal, whom the Dodgers had acquired. Brewers deadline acquisitions JoJo Romero and Antonio Senzatela made significant bullpen contributions during October, though some additions like Dustin May and Lance McCullers underperformed. By avoiding the Skubal trade, Arnold preserved prospects Logan Henderson and Luis Peña, protecting the franchise's long-term future while still positioning Milwaukee to compete immediately. The strategy reflects the Brewers' organizational philosophy of sustained competitiveness rather than short-term all-in approaches.
Reviewing the BrewBrewers bullpen’s record-breaking performance showcases depth of NLCS pitching staff
The Brewers took a 2-0 series lead over the Dodgers in the NLCS by winning Game 2 at home. Four relievers—Dustin May, JoJo Romero, Abner Uribe, and Aaron Ashby—combined to pitch five perfect innings, setting an all-time postseason record with 15 consecutive outs without allowing a baserunner. The Brewers' bullpen depth, built on versatile pitchers acquired over the summer including May and Romero from the Cardinals, has proven capable of handling various situations and opposing hitters throughout the postseason.
Reviewing the BrewBrewers stray from NLDS strategy with Game 3 starting pitcher assignment in NLCS
Manager Pat Murphy initially chose Dustin May for Game 3 of the NLDS against San Diego, prioritizing postseason experience over Robert Gasser's superior consistency and recent performance. After May struggled in that game while Gasser impressed in Game 4, Murphy reversed course and named Gasser the Game 3 starter for the NLCS. Since late August, Gasser has allowed no more than two earned runs in any start and the Brewers have won seven of his last eight outings.
Reviewing the BrewBrewers' unchanged NLCS roster gives Pat Murphy necessary versatility in rematch with Dodgers
The Brewers kept their same 26-player roster for the NLCS against the Dodgers, including three pitchers who didn't appear in the NLDS: Kyle Harrison, Shane Drohan, and Chad Patrick. Manager Pat Murphy expects all three to play roles in the best-of-seven series, particularly in Games 3 and 4 where the team may use creative pitching combinations like pairing a left-hander with Dustin May. The extended format of the NLCS compared to the shorter NLDS makes deeper pitching depth more valuable for managing matchups and covering potential extra innings.
Reviewing the BrewBrewers and Dodgers’ 2026 trade deadline outcome to play key role in NLCS rematch
The Dodgers acquired two-time AL Cy Young winner Tarik Skubal from the Brewers in a major trade deadline deal, and he has posted a 2.61 ERA over 62 regular-season innings while helping Los Angeles reach the NLCS. The Brewers countered by acquiring Dustin May and JoJo Romero from the Cardinals to bolster their rotation and bullpen, with Romero providing a left-handed relief option against the Dodgers' left-handed heavy lineup. Both teams made strategic deadline moves that will significantly impact their NLCS rematch, though Skubal figures to be the most influential acquisition.
Reviewing the BrewPat Murphy faces familiar Game 3 starter decision in Brewers' NLCS rematch with Dodgers
The Brewers face a familiar decision with manager Pat Murphy choosing between Dustin May and rookie Robert Gasser for Game 3 of their NLCS rematch against the Dodgers. In the recent NLDS against San Diego, Murphy started May in Game 3 and Gasser in Game 4, with May allowing two runs over three innings and Gasser giving up one run over four innings. May has a 3.20 career ERA at Dodger Stadium with one appearance against Los Angeles this season, while Gasser has faced the Dodgers twice in 2026, posting a strong 2.00 ERA in his August outing at their stadium. Murphy may repeat his NLDS strategy of using the veteran May on the road while giving Gasser a chance to observe before pitching, though both pitchers operated on short leashes previously.
Reviewing the Brew3 reasons to believe this year's Brewers-Dodgers NLCS matchup will end differently than last year's
The Brewers face the Dodgers in the NLCS for the second consecutive year after defeating the Padres in the NLDS. Last year Milwaukee was swept in four games while scoring just four total runs, but this year their pitching staff is significantly stronger, led by NL Cy Young front-runner Jacob Misiorowski, who had the best single-season performance by a Brewers pitcher in franchise history. The rotation is also deeper than last year, with rookie Logan Henderson, Dustin May, and Robert Gasser providing additional options beyond Misiorowski, along with arms like Shane Drohan and Kyle Harrison available for the series.
Reviewing the BrewPat Murphy's Game 3 batting order tweak changes Jackson Chourio's lineup protection
Manager Pat Murphy restructured the Milwaukee Brewers' batting order for Game 3 of their NLDS against San Diego, moving Jake Bauers to the two-hole, William Contreras to third, and Brice Turang to cleanup—a lineup combination the team never used during the regular season. The change addresses opposing pitchers' focus on Jackson Chourio by providing him different protection, as Turang went hitless in the first two games despite batting directly behind Chourio in both contests. Joey Ortiz replaces David Hamilton at third base, while Dustin May starts for the Brewers against Padres right-hander Nick Pivetta in Milwaukee's first road playoff game.
Reviewing the BrewNLDS Game 3 Discussion: Milwaukee Brewers (2-0) @ San Diego Padres (0-2)
The Milwaukee Brewers seek to complete a sweep of the San Diego Padres in Game 3 of the NLDS, with right-hander Dustin May taking the mound against Padres starter Nick Pivetta. May has pitched well against San Diego in the past, including a one-hit shutout earlier this season, while Pivetta has struggled historically against Milwaukee despite an excellent 2024 regular season. Jackson Chourio, who starred in Sunday's game, leads off for the Brewers with first pitch scheduled for 8:38 p.m. CT on FS1.
Brew Crew BallDustin May's stats show he is the perfect guy to close out Padres, but how long will his leash be?
The Milwaukee Brewers acquired Dustin May from the St. Louis Cardinals at the trade deadline, giving up a pair of outfield prospects along with JoJo Romero. Despite posting a 5.65 ERA in 36.2 innings down the stretch with Milwaukee, the Brewers named the 29-year-old as their Game 3 starter against the Padres, banking on his strong track record and particular success against San Diego. May has faced the Padres three times in 2026 and owns a 3.02 ERA with a .182 opponent batting average at Petco Park across his career, including a complete-game shutout against them in June.
Reviewing the BrewPadres Activate Walker Buehler Onto NLDS Roster
The Padres activated Walker Buehler from the paternity list ahead of Game 3 of their NLDS against the Brewers, replacing Randy Vásquez on the roster. Buehler will be available in relief for Game 3 and could potentially start Game 4 if the Padres force one. Nick Pivetta will start Game 3 for San Diego against Dustin May, with the Padres facing elimination after losing the first two games in Milwaukee.
MLB Trade RumorsNLDS Game 2 Discussion: Milwaukee Brewers (1-0) vs San Diego Padres (0-1)
The Brewers aim to take a 2-0 series lead against the Padres in Game 2, with right-hander Logan Henderson making his postseason debut against Padres ace Michael King, who allowed just one hit across seven innings in his Wild Card start. Milwaukee's offense, led by Jackson Chourio batting leadoff, will attempt to disrupt King's command after the Brewers used five relievers to cover the final five innings in Game 1. The Brewers will need Henderson to provide extended length on the mound, and the game will be played with the roof open under clear skies. Manager Pat Murphy has also named Dustin May as the Game 3 starter in San Diego.
Brew Crew BallBrewers favor experience in naming Dustin May NLDS Game 3 starter
Manager Pat Murphy selected Dustin May to start Game 3 of the NLDS against San Diego on Tuesday night, prioritizing postseason experience over rookie Robert Gasser despite May's weaker September numbers. May has nine playoff appearances including three starts, while Gasser has minimal postseason experience with only 2.2 relief innings. May also brings familiarity with Petco Park, where he has pitched 47.2 innings with a 3.02 ERA and recently threw a seven-inning gem against the Padres in August.
Reviewing the BrewBrewers announce 2026 NLDS roster complete with stacked pitching staff
The Milwaukee Brewers announced their 2026 NLDS roster with 13 pitchers and 13 position players, departing from the typical 12-pitcher format most teams use for best-of-five series. This decision allowed the Brewers to include both Kyle Harrison and Dustin May on the roster while forgoing a third catcher. Jacob Misiorowski and Logan Henderson are scheduled to start Games 1 and 2, with the Game 3 starter still uncertain, making the extra pitching depth potentially valuable for the series against the San Diego Padres.
Reviewing the BrewHow matchup with Padres could impact Brewers' NLDS pitching strategy
The Brewers and Padres are meeting in the postseason for the first time despite both teams' frequent playoff appearances in recent years. San Diego's lineup features several strong right-handed hitters, including Manny Machado, Fernando Tatis Jr., and Xander Bogaerts, who have all performed well against left-handed pitching, which could influence Milwaukee's roster construction and pitching strategy. The Padres demonstrated this strength by hitting three home runs off left-hander Matthew Boyd in their Wild Card Series against the Cubs. Manager Pat Murphy may opt to rely more heavily on right-handed starters and fewer left-handed relievers, making the decision between Dustin May and Robert Gasser for Game 3 particularly significant.
Reviewing the BrewGame Discussion: Milwaukee Brewers (101-59) vs St. Louis Cardinals (77-83)
The Brewers seek their 102nd win tonight against the Cardinals with Dustin May on the mound for a final regular season audition before the postseason. Milwaukee's third baseman Joey Ortiz underwent an MRI after being removed yesterday due to a right knee bruise, and the team learned he's also dealing with an abdominal strain and groin injury, forcing the Brewers to operate with a short bench within 10 days of the NLDS. May has pitched in short outings recently and will look to stretch deeper into this game while refining his pitch sequencing against Cardinals left-hander Quinn Mathews, who carries a 3.65 ERA.
Brew Crew BallSeries Preview: Milwaukee Brewers vs. St. Louis Cardinals
The Brewers enter their series against the Cardinals at 99 wins and need just two more victories or a combination of wins and Dodgers losses to secure the No. 1 overall seed. Milwaukee's offense is led by Jake Bauers, Jackson Chourio, and Brice Turang, who each have over 20 home runs, while the Cardinals counter with Jordan Walker, who is on pace for a top-five MVP finish with 28 homers and 100 RBIs. The Brewers will start Robert Gasser on Friday against Michael McGreevy, with Dustin May scheduled for Saturday against Quinn Mathews.
Brew Crew Ball3 things Brewers must tighten up in final week before MLB playoffs begin
The Milwaukee Brewers have clinched the NL Central for the fourth consecutive year and secured a first-round bye, leaving four games to prepare for October baseball. Manager Pat Murphy has begun limiting pitcher workloads and managing injuries, such as keeping Jake Bauers out of the field with shin splints, to prioritize postseason readiness over winning regular season games. The team must decide whether to use Dustin May or Robert Gasser as their third playoff starter, with May offering higher upside but inconsistency, while Gasser provides reliability with less strikeout stuff.
Reviewing the BrewWhy Brewers leaning towards Dustin May as Game 3 starter raises their playoff rotation's ceiling
The Brewers are leaning toward Dustin May as their Game 3 playoff starter over rookie Robert Gasser, despite Gasser's superior recent performance. May brings nine postseason appearances from his time with the Dodgers in 2019 and 2020, compared to Gasser's minimal playoff experience, which was a key reason Milwaukee acquired him at the trade deadline. While Gasser has posted better numbers since early August, May possesses superior strikeout stuff and a higher chase rate that could prove valuable in October baseball.
Reviewing the BrewGame Discussion: Milwaukee Brewers (98-58) @ Philadelphia Phillies (86-70)
The Brewers, baseball's best team at 98-58, face the Phillies tonight in Philadelphia during the final week of the regular season. Brewers starter Dustin May has struggled with a 5.40 ERA in eight starts and needs a strong outing to secure his postseason role, though he has an advantage with most Phillies hitters unfamiliar with him. The Phillies, currently holding the third wild card spot, will counter with Zach Wheeler, who recently threw seven scoreless innings against Washington and has faced most of the Brewers lineup multiple times. First pitch is at 5:40 p.m. at Citizens Bank Park.
Brew Crew Ball